11 replies to this topic

[Rabbit]

anyone BUT ollie the magic bum is welcome to reply

[.Jon.]

yellow looks too bold, text is a little hard to read, rounded borders look stupid usually, blending is pretty good, use more and different colors. Also, if ur going to do a COD4 sig, at least use a COD4 render. COD3 renders arent workin here, dont try to defend it cause i have COD3 with that EXACT same render/soldier on it.

Whats ur beef with Ollie? lol.

[Sharpshooter93]

Text is very hard to see. Try a diff color. not liking the gold to much. Go for a more dirty look. Not bad, but could use improvements

8/10

[Showtime]

If you post it here, it means that anyone is welcome to reply. If you don't like his comments then ignore them, but as long as he is following the rules it's fine, his opinion is his opinion.

But yeah uhm... about the sig. Could use some color variation but I don't think it's too bad really, aside from the subtext. I think the border is kinda cool because the shape it reminds me of an army tag.

[EndZone]

That bevel effect on the sig is random and doesn't feel right.

Sig feels kinda dark and lacking in color.

Try to add coloring and spice it up. It's kinda boring at the moment.

[Ollie The Magic Bum]

Rabbit, on Jan 28 2008, 10:36 PM, said:

anyone BUT ollie the magic bum is welcome to reply

Oh, I can feel the love.

Good choice of font for the "call of duty" portion. Not so good for the "modern warfare" part. The whole thing is kinda monotonous too. Doesn't really capture the whole feel of the game. Maybe something on a larger canvas?

[Atheist]

Text is good, colors are decent, the rest is meh.

And as KBD stated, you can choose whether or not to post, but you can't pick who comments or not. This is a graphics community, sometimes you get feedback you like, sometimes not.

[Rabbit]

well ollie barely ever gives me constructive critism

at times he just says to stuff i do "it sucks start over"

not saying what to do diffrently and/or what to do the same

[Ollie The Magic Bum]

Check your PM's sir.

[Rabbit]

EndZone, on Jan 30 2008, 07:31 PM, said:

That bevel effect on the sig is random and doesn't feel right.

Sig feels kinda dark and lacking in color.

Try to add coloring and spice it up. It's kinda boring at the moment.

which bevel we talking about here?

[Showtime]

He means the glow around the border, looks kinda like the whole sig is embossed

[Corporal Hicks]

The glow around the boarder sucks, The "Call Of Duty" text works but the rest of it doesn't, Not to keen on the single colour tone, It makes it very flat and boring.